![]() |
||
| R E V I E W S |
||
| Hiwassee
Freedom's Altar The Cock's Spur Where the
Water-Dogs Laughed |
||
Reviews of Where
the Water-Dogs Laughed "One of the major themes in Cherokee folklore concerns the sacred covenant between Man and Nature. Many of the ancient tales illustrate the delicate, mystical ties that traditional Cherokees believe exist between “The Great Trinity” — man, plant and animal. Frequently, the Cherokee myths not only recount heroic adventures and fabulous quests — they also contain a cautionary warning: Be mindful of the covenant, they say. Observe the rituals that maintain the fragile balance of Creation, for failure to do so can rend the sacred bonds that hold this world together.... Read the rest of Gary Carden's review from the Smoky Mountain News.
"Price's latest work brilliantly
mines the legends and history of the Southern mountains, much as his
others have done, and this may be his most successful work to date.
Certainly it is his most audacious. The title stems from an ancient
Cherokee myth in which a hunter crossing Tusquittee Bald saw two
waterdogs (salamanders) walking together on their hind legs until they
came to a pond that had dried up after a prolonged drought. As the
hunter listened, one said to the other, "Where's the water? I'm so
thirsty that my gills are hanging down," and then both waterdogs had a
hearty laugh. Where the Water-Dogs Laughed is also what the Cherokees
have for ages called the white man's far less imaginatively named
Tusquittee Bald.
"Price, a former
reporter for the Greensboro News & Record, recounts a tale that
brings to life many of the characters in his previous books. This time,
however, they share space with Yan-e'gwa, a giant mountain bear whom
the author endows with reason and whose destiny, the bear believes, is
to fulfill a covenant established in Cherokee lore at a time when bears
and men were brothers and companions."
"There is no single
protagonist in the novel, but a wide range of characters have their
moment on stage and the author is skilled enough to let each one shine
through with his or her individual voice. Some, such as the bitter
Hamby McFee, the lovelorn Will Price and the somewhat obnoxious George
Wetherby, are a little louder than the others, but every character is
lovingly crafted and presented for their moment in the spotlight. The
mythical element provided by the bear is an integral part of the story
and although I was dubious at first, I was pleasantly surprised at how
well it actually works in the tale. It's a powerful novel, beautifully
told and saturated in the atmosphere of its Appalachian landscape.
Readers will probably benefit from reading the previous novels in the
series to obtain a more complete history of the families concerned, but
I have no hesitation in highly recommending this particular episode. |
||
| |
|
|
Reviews
of The Cock's Spur"Lyrically
written, character-rich and authentically atmospheric, the novel
affords a
deeply affecting insight into the aftermath of war." "The
Cock's Spur stands alone as a classic work of literature... Barriers of
time
and culture drop, as Price's gifted, natural writing puts you right on
the spot
in the early 1880's... It's geneology made into authentic fiction." "(Price
is) a rip-roaring good novelist... The Cock's Spur is a tale in the
grand
tradition... He doesn't preach. But the theme is ultimately a serious
one, the
challenge of duty. Price's well-rounded depiction of...hardscrabble
challenges...test the moral values and plain courage of his people.
Their
responses make a rousing story of hearts in conflict..." "The
Cock's Spur is a much bigger book than its 300-plus pages. It's
also
perhaps
the best of a batch of recently published novels (Cold Mountain, In the
Fall,
Gap Creek, etc.) that represent the Appalachians and their
people
during the
turbulent Civil War era and after. What makes the book unique,
separating it
from the many others of its ilk, is the fact that, as in his previous
two
books...Price once more shines the literary light on his own
ancestors... There
is rarely a languid moment, never a dull scene. This is a sweeping
novel of
cockfights and gunfights, of moonshine-running and old blood feuds. of
pride
and honor...and dishonor. But it's not romantic, as many books with
similar
settings have been. The reader isn't spared the gritty details of a
time and
place where, often, only self-imposed law ruled the day. And yet the
book's
beauty fidgets in some of its most horrible details.... "The
Cock's Spur is not without its tenderness, however. In fact,...I
direct
readers
to a scene near the end that's as powerful as the dying scene in
Hemingway's
‘Snows of Kilimanjaro’. The novels' final chapters certify the theme of
redemption without the usual maudlin closure that a lesser writer might
bring
in to ruin an otherwise crackling good tale." "[W]e
readers immediately fall under the spell of the storyteller...
[Price's] plot
is finely drawn. His characters intrigue us... In superb scene-setting
based on
careful research, he writes of poverty and the tyranny of the powerful,
fatal
illness with no remedy, and the striving of humans to make the best of
what
they have in a harsh environment... [The
Cock's Spur is] a perfect Christmas
gift to Western North Carolina from one of its outstanding sons." "Moonshining,
cock-fighting, race relations and psychotic mountain men thrive in his
novel
set in Western North Carolina in the 1880's. Price's passion for
details and
his earthy portrayal of men living close to the earth - and even closer
to the
edge - move the story forward, with occasional stops along the way
for...melodrama..." "Price
has produced one of the most eloquent and honest historical novels of
the
post-Civil War South... (He) is serenely and confidently at home in the
late
19th century. His characters speak with the roughness of the times,
frequently
in a voice that may offend the politically correct. He does not flinch
from
portraying the racial tensions of the era, the rise of the Ku Klux
Klan, the
Kirk-Holden War, and the heavy hand of the federal government in the
post-war
South. "A
truly original voice that resonates like the hill country he writes
about.
Price is leading a new wave of great Southern writing and publishing." Independent
Publisher Book Awards
2001 Naming Price Storyteller of the
Year and The Cock's Spur One of the Ten
Outstanding Books of 2001
"Price's
writing has tremendous power and clarity, and I say with delight that
his
characters are firmly of their time. There is not a shred of political
correctness..., no delicacy in the descriptions of the terrible
symptoms of
consumption and dementia, or...torture.... The novel is very dark at
times and
is not for the squeamish, but it is also tremendously uplifting and
possessed
of a spiritual resonance. In my opinion it well deserves the accolade
of being
the Independent Publisher's outstanding book of 2001." Susan
Hicks - The Historical Novels Review - February 19, 2002 back to Books |
||
| |
|
|
Reviews
of Freedom's Altar"In this sequel to his well-received Hiwassee, Price again shows that he can write absorbing and moving historical fiction.... Price has based his narrative on his family's own genealogy...; while he has taken fictional liberties, his narrative has an authoritative resonance and his prose is invested with quiet confidence. Against a fascinatingly detailed backdrop of the decaying and lawless postslavery South, Price eloquently addresses questions of race and class and morality, poignantly exploring whether hope and loyalty can exist in a world where war has damaged lives irrevocably." Publishers Weekly "Many
will compare this book to Cold Mountain... Like that novel, Freedom's
Altar is rich with detail and description... You can smell the moist,
shadowed air of the high forests, and you can feel the fallow soil of
the post-war South between your fingers... But where Cold Mountain was
at its essence a romantic novel of a reluctant soldier's journey home,
Freedom's Altar is something different - a profound, well-told tale of
a family's struggle to survive and cope during the most trying of
times." "Add
to all this the graceful dignity of Price's prose, his portrait of the
mountains themselves as a character in his narrative, his realistic
portrayal of the physical suffering human beings endured in a time when
medicine was primitive and death was often agonizingly painful, and his
compassion for the human flaws that make even wise men ultimately
vulnerable. The result is a saga that begs at the very least for the
lens of the cinematographer and at most for a readership that could
propel it not just to bestsellerdom but attract a major literary award." "...(O)ne
gets a terrifically engaging history lesson about Reconstruction in the
South, particularly North Carolina... Price enlivens history by
fittingly using distinctive families to dramatize the catastrophic (and
ongoing) consequences of the Civil War as well as the agonizing and
often violent process of national reconciliation.... Freedom's
Altar...is...a thoughtful, and often compelling, book." "Price
is a gifted storyteller, and his straightforward style and simple
characters belie the complexity of the ideas he presents through them.
You don't have to wrangle the meaning out of a Price character; you'd
be blind to miss it, yet the message rarely seems forced.... (His)
great strength as a writer is his ability to vividly express himself
with simple, engaging language.... Price turns his pen with equal
facility on a frosted mountain path or a bereft mother's musings on the
place of pride and the lack of a place for God in man's affairs...
"(Freedom's Altar) is a rare type of novel: It's simply but beautifully
told, morally charged without seeming contrived or overbearing, and
it's entertaining to boot." "The
War Between the States has proved to be a fathomless source of literary
inspiration, and Price continues to produce flawless jewels from that
well... (He) addresses...harsh realities with compassion and clarity.
He writes as if from inside the soul of each character so that we see
what they saw and feel what they felt. We feel the dislocation, loss,
confusion and blazing resentment... One of Price's gifts is the ability
to speak in the character's voice without appearing to do so. Moving
from narrative to conversation to descriptions of local superstitions
and practices, he never fails to choose the perfect cadences. The altar
of freedom defined in this book is bloody and dark, but piercing
through this desperate image we find honor, charity and hope... Times
change. People change with them. At no time were these verities more
powerfully evident than in the years following the Civil War. No one
has evoked those changes better than Price." "To
his credit, Price sets up [the] conflict of race, class and economic
dismemberment without stereotyping the principal actors. From the
wealthiest landowner to the most destitute sharecropper, one has the
sense that living, breathing souls populate Freedom's Altar. Thus,
while the book's historical accuracy is undeniable, it is the human
vulnerability of the characters that makes it memorable.” "Freedom's
Altar is set in the mountains of North Carolina, and it is evident
Price wants his audience to feel as if they were viewing the mountains
as precisely as his characters might... [He] describes in detail the
leaves of the rhododendron...and conveys how the mountain ranges are
pale shades of blue... The character development progresses in a way
that lets you get to know and care about each person. ...Price
incorporates female characters who are essential to the story, and he
has done a remarkable job placing the reader into the minds of these
women...Freedom's Altar, a fine literary work, addresses the
relationship between the races, an issue Southerners, and all
Americans, still face each day." "Charles Price catapulted to the
attention of Civil War readers three years ago with Hiwassee, an
unusually well-received first novel that is based on the wartime
experiences of his Southern Appalachian forebears... In fact those
readers were so enthralled by Hiwassee that it earned Price...the
reputation of a spellbinder in the realm of Civil War fiction. Happily,
the reading pleasures crafted into Freedom's Altar both confirm and
deepen that reputation. And for those left longing for a sequel at
Hiwassee's end, yes, the new novel is just that. [E]legiac,...[l]onger,
more complex,...[In] part this gripping, hard-to-put-down novel is
about father-son and other male relationships. But...overarchingly [it]
is about tragically squandered opportunities to begin the process of
racial reconciliation in the war's embittered aftermath....Price's
stellar creation is to be relished for its...beauties of prose. Indeed,
the unforgettable final scene pierces the heart." |
||
Reviews
of Hiwassee: A Novel of the Civil War
"...Price
succeeds in capturing the harsh realities of the countless sideshows of
the Civil War in regions that have been obscured by large military
campaigns, though he does it in an engaging way. The characters are
vivid [and] compelling and the dialogue crisp. He captures the anxiety
and emotion of soldiers and women on the home front. The often phrased
brother-against-brother characterization comes to life in this novel.
[Price] successfully combines social and military history in a moving
narrative. Though this is [his] first novel, one can hardly assume it
will be his last." "Good
historical fiction brings the world it evokes down to a personal level,
a process accomplished very well in this first novel...a tight, almost
elegantly written, yet piercingly honest first novel all readers of
historical fiction will appreciate." "Forceful and
gritty, Price's debut is a gripping tale of brutality and sacrifice
during the Civil War... Price's narrative is crisp and vivid, with
sharply focused descriptions and dialogue." "Reading almost like an expose of life in
the Confederate army, Hiwassee is
that rare thing: a short Civil War novel. The intensity is high,
however, and we begin to care for these authentic characters very
quickly." "Through
the evolution of the story, the reader is reminded that even against
the background of national fratricide, individual stories have their
own impetus and precedence in the day-to-day living out of life...
(Price's) story...is no less useful in refocusing our attention on the
personal aspects of life during any war." "In the course of researching his roots, Charles
Price has created a gem of a novel... More than other Civil War
histories, Hiwassee tells a story of the civilian side of the war.
Additionally, the rich description of the events and the countryside
makes this (book) a pleasure to read." "Price's
beautifully evocative prose imparts a sense of immediacy to the
landscape of valley, hill, field, stream, and forest and conveys the
menace of war's depredations on the daily lives of ordinary people who
thought they were involved in a gallant cause, only to be brought
face-to-face with its uglier realities." "Hiwassee is by turns movingly, horrifyingly and
bracingly specific... Billed as fiction, [it] has the ring of a true
story... Hiwassee is...packed with details of what it was like to fight
in the war..." "Price's forte is description - the sights and smells,
the expressions on the faces. It's not a story for the fainthearted...
The author does his best writing when he describes the military
engagements... The Battle of Chickamauga is presented not as a chess
match of generals, but as a bloody, irrational and frightening bit of
organized chaos... Hiwassee is an easy, believable read that is hard to
put down." "...(A)
tight, finely structured novel. (Price) does more in 188 pages to
capture the essence of the war than Ken Burns did in 15 hours of
videotape... (He) gives us believable characters, a high level of
drama, and that which is most necessary in first-rate fiction: a sense
of surprise and astonishment... Hiwassee is an impressive debut..." "How
a book reviewer lives to utter these words: This first novel marks the
appearance of a significant new voice on the American literary scene...
Sparsely yet beautifully written in its author's unconscious Southern
cadence, Hiwassee's remarkable achievement is in its ground-level
evocation of the emotional experience of war..." "Price
paints his native North Carolina beautifully, from the mist on the
mountaintops to the taste of the water in the Hiwassee River (old
pennies). Seen through the eyes of a true native, the Hiwassee Valley
takes on an almost mythical beauty, and its scourging is as painful as
anything the characters themselves go through. ...There is always
something enchanting in the voice of an author who truly loves the
story he is telling, and Hiwassee offers that enchantment on every
page." "A grim, convincing, remarkably assured first novel
about the darker byways of the Civil War... Throughout, ...Price brings
an astonishing versimilitude to the narrative. The salty, exact
language, tough-minded views, hard lives, and bloody deeds of these
characters ring true throughout... Few recent novels have caught with
such conviction the true texture and profound emotions of that
conflict." "True to history, Price's realism recreates a
neighbor-against-neighbor warfare that is often tidily forgotten. In
his portrait of battle between 'organized' forces, he does for
Chickamauga what The Killer Angels did for Gettysburg; the section
reads as if a powder-blackened private had sent an honest letter home." "In this remarkable novel Mr. Price, with
consummate skill, draws his reader inexorably into the ugly underside
of the American Civil War. None of the pageantry of the great conflict
is here, for the author has chosen to tell instead a gripping narrative
of the North Carolina mountains and valleys, remote from the vast
canvases of the war, where passions nonetheless ran high and ruthless
freebooters, under the guise of dedicated partisans, preyed on 'secesh'
and unionists alike. In doing so, Charles F. Price has written an
account that rings with realism and authenticity." "Charles
Price's Hiwassee is first rate Civil War fiction. More than that, it
pulls the reader into a hidden corner of the war. Against the backdrop
of big war, the author writes lyrically of North Carolina mountain
places and people. He evokes the grim side of Civil War living in
guerrilla-ridden border areas, a side rarely offered in most war books.
The characters ring true, the dialogue is right, the mood exciting -
and the book is hard to put down!" "This
is a tough book. Readers will not forget the anxiety of men and,
particularly, women on the home front. Equally memorable are the
marauders, the meanest groups I've read about recently, here brought to
life (yes, and death). Then there is the plight of soldiers in the
ranks of the ever-shifting Confederate army. The novel seeps
authenticity. Many of the people show grit and inherent dignity." "Reading
Hiwassee is not a full-scale campaign...but rather like being in a
quick, sharp skirmish. Price's crisp writing style and command of Civil
War history keeps each page of his book fresh as a mountain breeze.
While entertaining, Hiwassee is also an education into the tumultuous
life many Tar Heels had to endure in the Civil War." "Set
in the Appalachians during the Civil War, Hiwassee is an impressive
recreation of one of the little known aspects of that conflict. More
importantly, it's an intelligent, finely-structured novel, one in which
the believability of the characters meshes perfectly with the setting
and action. Even if you're tired of Civil War books, Hiwassee is
recommended." |
||
|
|
||